Showing posts with label gun control. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gun control. Show all posts
Monday, January 11, 2021
Friday, February 16, 2018
Another day, another mass murder, Valentine's Day edition
![]() |
| "Give Blood" - Public domain |
DeeDee Snavely,
A Tuna Christmas
* * *
Let's weigh in on the latest mass murder, this one at a high school in Parkland, Florida. Why not? Or as the President would say, "What have you got to lose?" I'm sure my words will make all the difference in the world because clearly the National Rifle Association (NRA), the U.S. Congress, the President, and America's gun fetishists are swayed by words and moral arguments.
* * *
I've begun to look at the problem of mass shootings in this way--coldly, cynically, just like our political leaders and gun manufacturers' national "safe space" support group--in an effort to think about strategies that might help end this madness. Essentially, it comes down to this realization: The NRA isn't bothered by mass killings because they're actually good for business. When these crimes happen, more people buy guns, which makes gun manufacturers and retailers happier and wealthier. (Hello, Wal-Mart!)
Happy, wealthy manufacturers and retailers are then likely to give more money to the NRA and to conservative politicians. This, in turn, makes conservative politicians happy, wealthy, and supportive of pro-gun policies.
Which leads me to believe that the NRA's one true love is gun manufacturers and retailers. The image of the "patriot" defending his home(land) and his (property) rights, the brave little "citizen soldier," the well-armed militia--these are just ruses to make gun ownership and gun hoarding seem like patriotism and good citizenship. It brings in the rank-and-file membership, the on-the-ground support, but it obfuscates who their real passions are.
It's as if there had been a National Cigarette Organization (was there?) and the Marlboro Man was trotted out to show how smoking is the perfect symbol of manhood, rugged individualism, and The American Way.
But the first clue about the organization's intent is in the name--it's not the National Cigarette Smokers Organization, and it's not the National Rifle Aficionados League. The emphasis is clearly on cigarettes and rifles, the products themselves. All hail the goods!
* * *
For anyone paying attention, the bodies piling up, the gaping wounds, the kids on the floor screaming in their classrooms as bullets fly overhead, should have suggested long ago that gun manufacturing, selling, ownership, and frequent use are not emblematic of good citizenship.
But might this be an argument rooted in emotions? We're assaulted, figuratively and literally, by so many images of crime and violence, by so many actual crimes and violence, that it's become very easy--even very necessary--to turn on, tune in, and then drop out as soon as possible, in order to handle the reality overload.
So we become inured and even cynical about these crimes. Why didn't they run away? Why didn't they stay put? Why didn't they do more drills? Why didn't they report their fellow citizens for fiery words and thought crimes? Why are they crying? It's their fault, not ours, for letting it continue to happen.
In this climate, though, however well-meaning, we keep using emotional arguments to win over the NRA and its supporters when for them--and perhaps most of us--emotions have nothing to do with it. For the NRA and its menage-a-trois relationship with manufacturers and retailers, it's all about the cold, hard cash. For the rest of us, we're just trying to get through the day, working for The Man, and hoping not to get shot.
I don't know how you easily counter the "pure" Capitalist reason of the NRA or the detached attitude many of us have to adopt to survive. Some people are cold and selfish, and nothing moves them to do the right thing. Others are just worn out and under siege.
But some shocks to the system might help. Normally, I would recommend a few well-tossed Molotov cocktails at appropriate places and persons, but then the NRA and its fanboys and fangirls would advocate that gasoline, lighters, and glass bottles should be restricted--at least until they could make some investments in the right natural resources and industries.
So why not use their implement of choice--guns of all varieties but perhaps with a special focus on the AR-15? I'm not suggesting anyone commit an actual crime. I mean, none of us is a terrorist or a mental patient, right? Ain't nobody here but law-abiding citizens!
Rather start by doing what's completely legal--show up packing heat in classrooms, hospitals, at your kids' recital, at weddings, and at funerals; "stand your ground" whenever you or your property feel threatened; tackle Wayne LaPierre, a member of the Walton family, or Marco Rubio because they look shady and like they might resist arrest.
And then if that doesn't do it, get more creative and emphatic.
* * *
In the U.S., we allowed slavery of African Americans until the 1860s, and once that was done, we had sharecropping and Jim Crow's spoken and unspoken laws to keep African Americans under society's collective thumb. Here's where I would make the stale ol' Southern argument--it was a matter of economics (and a lack of concern for human rights) that kept the system in place. There was money to be made and people's feelings to be disregarded. Capitalism excels at this.
Appealing to people's better angels did help reveal the tragedy, the horror, the abuse, and the cruelty. But it only went so far. People had to protest, fight, and legislate to make things better.
I think appealing to emotions, feelings, and our better natures is important, but sadly you can't expect everyone to be swayed by the same approach. They may not be swayed at all. And thus you have to take bold decisive action--protests, battles (literal battles, in the streets), court cases, and laws--to win.
So the overabundance of firearms to me is like the system of chattel slavery--it's abusive Capitalism and what's being abused is our human rights. We should look back to our past to see how we handled the great moral crises of our times, learn from them, and act accordingly.
Tuesday, November 07, 2017
Shoot the messenger
![]() |
| "Clock in the main station, Zürich, Switzerland" by JuergenG; modified by Rainer Z. CC BY-SA 3.0 Unported. |
*This appointment may be suspended if a horrific shooting occurs prior to the designated time or is believed likely to happen after the designated time.
(Hey, don’t shoot the messenger! The National Rifle Association sets the rules, not me.)
(Oh, who am I kidding? You’re totally allowed to shoot the messenger. Wouldn’t want to be accused of interfering with your 2nd Amendment rights. Unfettered access to firearms über alles and all that.)
Monday, November 06, 2017
To good mental health, Mr. President
And because it's not a guns situation, can we assume that Our Fearless Leader won't be bothered when a brown terrorist or a white lone wolf starts "mental healthing" at him?
After all, the murderer isn't trying to shoot you. He's just trying to make a rush appointment for some mental health counseling.
Which he probably doesn't have access to because he has no health insurance... but let's not sweat the policy details of you and your colleagues in Congress.
After all, the murderer isn't trying to shoot you. He's just trying to make a rush appointment for some mental health counseling.
Which he probably doesn't have access to because he has no health insurance... but let's not sweat the policy details of you and your colleagues in Congress.
Check it out
A timely repost from Facebook . . .
I'd like to add a couple of items to this checklist, things I've noticed that have become part of the "national conversation" that leads to total inaction:
Time to break out the handy "Mass shooting in US checklist":
- Send thoughts & prayers but not actually do anything useful

- Argue over semantics of the term "assault rifle"

-
Argue over semantics of the term "terrorist" - if Muslim use it, if
Christian/white use term "lone wolf" "mentally ill" "troubled past"

- Congress does nothing but NRA increases donations just in case

- Wait for next one, rinse, repeat

- Report statistics that state more people die from handguns, car crashes, cancer, etc., to downplay the horror of mass shootings and indicate that mass shootings aren't really a problem after all.
- Argue that you can’t change or repeal the 2nd Amendment of the Constitution. (Hint: Yes, we can. The 2nd Amendment is already a change to the original Constitution.)
- Argue that the 2nd Amendment is your right--and a superior right at that. Ignore all other rights. Ignore the promise of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness in the U.S. Declaration of Independence. Continue to believe that your right to bear arms supersedes all other rights.
Thursday, November 24, 2016
Cradle to grave
From the November 22, 2016, New York Times:
"Supporters of the Second Amendment, ecstatic that Hillary Clinton lost, anticipate an expansion of gun rights with a Trump administration and a Republican-led Congress."
An expansion of gun rights? What would that even look like at this point?
Every time you open your mouth, you fire off several rounds from an automatic assault rifle lodged in your esophagus?
Frankly, with gun and ammunition sales robust before and after the election (when aren't they robust?), there aren't many areas for expansion of gun rights.
The womb maybe with every fetus a possible active shooter or a good zygote with a gun.
Or the coffin, just in case you need to shoot your way past Saint Peter at the Pearly Gates.
I can hardly wait.
To buy my own body armor.
"Supporters of the Second Amendment, ecstatic that Hillary Clinton lost, anticipate an expansion of gun rights with a Trump administration and a Republican-led Congress."
An expansion of gun rights? What would that even look like at this point?
Every time you open your mouth, you fire off several rounds from an automatic assault rifle lodged in your esophagus?
Frankly, with gun and ammunition sales robust before and after the election (when aren't they robust?), there aren't many areas for expansion of gun rights.
The womb maybe with every fetus a possible active shooter or a good zygote with a gun.
Or the coffin, just in case you need to shoot your way past Saint Peter at the Pearly Gates.
I can hardly wait.
To buy my own body armor.
Wednesday, June 24, 2015
Channeling our inner Don Quijote
| Magnolia a Verbania by Josep Renalias Lohen 11 (CC BY-SA 3.0; courtesy of Wikimedia Commons |
I'll try to have more to say for myself on the flipside of the month--at least once I've unpacked my computer and established an internet connection. It's a sign of modern times that packing and moving excepted, my current priorities in life are a bank account, a Hulu subscription, and good internet. Never mind the new job and the commute--I'm already busy with entertaining myself and spending money I haven't earned yet!
But one thing that has occupied my mind over the last week is the mass assassination of nine African-American worshippers at a Charleston, South Carolina, church on Wednesday, June 17, 2015. Not a lot has penetrated my consciousness of late, mostly due to the whiff of cardboard I seem to ingest every day, but this most definitely has. I think it brings up my somewhat tortured relationship with my country and my home region, plus a sense of guilt for leaving family and friends behind. I often worry who will be the next victim of "a bad guy with a gun" and whether it will be someone I know, family or friend.
It's not that I walk around worried about this all the time, mind you. It's not that I need to, actually. Despite the "cowboy" reputation of the U.S., I really don't see guns everywhere--although sometimes at night, I do hear them from the broken-down neighborhood on the other side of the railroad tracks, just a block away.
I don't generally feel unsafe in the U.S. But perhaps I should. I mean, there is occasional gunfire only a block or two away from my head and my bed. There is "active shooter" training at work. There is my sister's state wanting to allow for guns on the university campus where she works. There is me scoping out escape routes in restaurants should something bad happen. There are, what? 11,000+ gun deaths each year in the U.S., 55,000+ nonfatal gun injuries, and 138,000+ gun-aggravated assaults (at least according to statistics from FactCheck.org)? And yet two of these numbers represent a decrease over previous years?
Let that set in for a moment.
Now doesn't that still seem like an awfully large number? And what about the fact that gun ownership and gun manufacturing continue to increase?
You can keep arguing that "more guns make us safer," but with those kind of numbers, pardon me if I don't feel like cuddling up to and fellating my firearm at night.
(For the record, I don't own a gun, nor does anyone in my family. My Dad used to have a rifle for occasional hunting and to scare away unwanted residents from his backyard birdhouses, but that's about as firearms-friendly as it got at Chez Montag.)
* * *
![]() |
| Kudzu on trees in Atlanta, Georgia by Scott Ehardt (public domain); courtesy of Wikimedia Commons |
And the windmill we're currently tilting at is removing the Confederate flag from our sight. We've once again taken the wrong message from the racially motivated mass murder of 9 African-American worshippers in Charleston last week.
And that message should be this: A gun killed them all, not a flag.
Please don't misunderstand me: I've got no problem with removing the Confederate flag from public buildings; I've got little to no problem relegating that symbol to museums and reenactments. At one point in my life, I might have tried to participate in a nuanced discussion of that flag's multiple meanings, but, honestly, who needs to hear all that? Plus I think knowing what I know now--that the flag made its reappearance during the early 1960s Civil Rights standoffs, as a way for the South to say "FU" to the rest of the country--I would just be horribly, horribly wrong.
If you're looking
for a symbol of Southern uniqueness and pride, I dunno, try the magnolia
or the loblolly pine, the collard, or, heck, even kudzu. That stuff can
withstand anything.
While protesting the Confederate flag and the racism it symbolizes is all well, good, and necessary, I fear we're just letting the real culprits off the hook once again. I'm willing to bet that nearly every right-leaning politician piling on the issue right now knows this and is using it as a way to not deal with legislating meaningful firearms restrictions. And, hey, if they happen to make the Republican Party look sensitive to racial issues, bonus points.
Maybe it's a victory that Wal-Mart and Amazon are willing to stop selling the flag (at least until things cool down) and that manufacturers are willing to stop making the flag (at least until things cool down). But it all seems very hollow. And speaking of hollow, no one's volunteering to stop making hollow-point bullets.
While all this is going on and we're rending our garments in public, gun manufacturers are doing their best Alfred E. Newman impersonation: "What, me worry?"
Yes, I think racism is still a huge problem in this country--the murder of nine African Americans during Bible study is the recent, most heinous example, but there are many others. Cops killing black motorists and citizens who resist arrest or are merely under suspicion for . . . something (poverty? blackness? effrontery to white privilege?); high black unemployment and endemic economic disadvantage; the incredibly negative reaction by some to Barack Obama--a strong, impressive, educated, self-made man--being elected as President of the United States (twice no less). These are just a few that come to mind that I right this.
While protesting the Confederate flag and the racism it symbolizes is all well, good, and necessary, I fear we're just letting the real culprits off the hook once again. I'm willing to bet that nearly every right-leaning politician piling on the issue right now knows this and is using it as a way to not deal with legislating meaningful firearms restrictions. And, hey, if they happen to make the Republican Party look sensitive to racial issues, bonus points.
Maybe it's a victory that Wal-Mart and Amazon are willing to stop selling the flag (at least until things cool down) and that manufacturers are willing to stop making the flag (at least until things cool down). But it all seems very hollow. And speaking of hollow, no one's volunteering to stop making hollow-point bullets.
While all this is going on and we're rending our garments in public, gun manufacturers are doing their best Alfred E. Newman impersonation: "What, me worry?"
Yes, I think racism is still a huge problem in this country--the murder of nine African Americans during Bible study is the recent, most heinous example, but there are many others. Cops killing black motorists and citizens who resist arrest or are merely under suspicion for . . . something (poverty? blackness? effrontery to white privilege?); high black unemployment and endemic economic disadvantage; the incredibly negative reaction by some to Barack Obama--a strong, impressive, educated, self-made man--being elected as President of the United States (twice no less). These are just a few that come to mind that I right this.
So, yes, it's well past time to take down the Confederate flag and relegate to the history bin (or the trash bin, take your pick). It's well past time to recommit to fighting against he racism it represents.
Nonetheless, this just seems like the same ol', same ol'. Let's call for reparations for slavery when instead we should be clamoring for continuing community and individual investment in disenfranchised minority populations (and/or the poor in general). Maybe that's the point--aim for the symbolic, get the real. I question its effectiveness, but then again, no one ever thought gays would be allowed to serve in the military or get married.
I feel like we were trying to do this in the 1960s and 1970s--significant investment in the disenfranchised, leveling the playing field, providing opportunity. But by the 1980s, we stopped doing it. Maybe because it was too hard to do, or we just royally messed it up (tearing down neighborhoods to put everyone in projects? really?).
But maybe we just let ourselves get distracted. After all, there are so many other windmills out there at which we can tilt.
Thanks for your time. See you in July.
Saturday, April 05, 2014
Leave me alone
| From the BBC World News website, 5 April 2014 |
I know I should feel more sympathy for a guy who clearly is disturbed--no sane person would kill three people and keep on shooting, aiming to end a few more lives (or so I'm assuming). Depression, anxiety, possible post-traumatic stress disorder, and the recent passing of his mother.
And what kind of pencil-pushing, penny-pinching bureaucrat would deny his leave request in the first place?
Nevertheless, the correct response is not, "Hey, I know, I'll just get a gun and kill lots of people."
Except unless you live in the US of A. At least if history-repeating-itself over and over again is any indication.
Thanks, NRA and Congress. You're doing a heckuva job blaming video games and attempting to repeal healthcare reform. Respectively or otherwise.
Friday, August 23, 2013
Tuff love
| Screen capture from CNN |
From now on, whenever anyone uses the word "hero" in my presence, I'll just smile to myself and think of Antoinette Tuff.
Here's a woman who actually did it, saved people, put her life on the line, and didn't make it all about her. She made it about the kids, her colleagues, and yes, even the guy who would do all of them harm.
I'm no real fan of organized religion, but Ms. Tuff gains my praise and appreciation for putting her beliefs in action, making a difference, and contributing something good to humankind.
May we all be able to say that at the end of the day, at the end of our days.
Sunday, March 11, 2012
The it's-not-OK corral
I spent Thursday afternoon in lockdown in the office building where I work because a man with two semi-automatic handguns woke up that day and decided to go on a killing spree at the Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic here in Pittsburgh. As the result of his actions, two died (one of them being the shooter himself) and seven others were injured.
I was never in any danger during this event. My office is at least three or four miles from the hospital, although it is a branch of my employer's operations, and, thus, when they went on lockdown in Oakland, so did we. I think everyone in my office felt a little nervous at first, dis-eased by the unknown, the drama, and the repeated and rapid-fire (if you'll pardon the expression) calls and texts received from our employer's post-Virginia Tech warning system. A few of us were inconvenienced because we had appointments at other offices near the hospital, but I think everyone was pretty clear on not needing to venture near the neighborhood after this incident.
So impact on us? Minimal. After a couple of hours of being stuck inside our offices, we relaxed and propped open the card swipe-protected door, so that we could go to the bathroom and the water fountain.
We even resorted to some black humor. One of my colleagues, upon hearing that a police officer had been grazed by a bullet in the shootout, joked, "I can hear it now, 'I shot the sheriff, but I did not kill no deputy.'"
Ha.
"Just make sure you're singing it like Bob Marley and not Eric Clapton," I quipped. "I can't stand the Clapton version of that song."
Double ha. We slay us, don't we?
Except that two people did get slayed, the shooter and a 25-year-old psychiatric nurse named Michael Schaab, who worked with geriatric patients and had just gotten engaged to his girlfriend in February. Apparently, too, this was the second (and last) child of Mr. Schaab's parents, Mary and Harry Schaab, to be murdered. Less than two years ago, their daughter Nancy, 26, was killed during a domestic dispute by her boyfriend.
If you were ever trying to find a pure example of the meaning of the word "tragedy," here's where you would start.
Of course, we didn't know any of this at the time. Nevertheless, that joke's not so funny anymore, is it? If it ever was.
Given the details that we now know, I do feel especially reprehensible for my part in trivializing the afternoon's events. No family should ever have to endure what the Schaabs are going through. My heart goes out to them. The whole city's, the entire nation's should as well.
I'm not some moral puritan who thinks you can't have a laugh, even a bitter pill of one, at someone or something else's expense. Gallows humor is a coping mechanism, pure and simple, something we do as a way to scare away the distress and alleviate the upset from horrific events. For good or for ill, I think we Americans have excelled at this over the last decade or more. Lordy, we've had to, given an up-and-down economy, lingering social ills, threats of domestic terrorism, and the bizarre, incendiary actions of some to impose their visions of law and order upon us. It's laugh or cry most days. The gods bless The Daily Show with Jon Stewart and the Colbert Report. Many of us would have caved ages ago without them.
Moreover, humor, black or otherwise, is just a part of our national character.
As I state to others elsewhere who decry some of the events that take place in our country, these now-almost common workplace shootings a case in point, we're Americans, not Europeans. We're not even Canadians. We made a conscious decision more than 200 years ago to separate ourselves from European rule and to embrace a New World culture.
While our cultural stock is made up of Europeans, it is only partly so. Besides, Europe's a big, diverse place. Our heritage hails from all parts of Europe, not just Britain or Northern or Western Europe. We are Southern European and Eastern European as well, as much Italian and Jewish as we are German, English, and Irish, I would argue. And we are also African, Latino, Asian, and indigenous as well. Heavily so and increasingly so and hooray for that.
I'd argue that we're actually spiritually more akin to Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, and the rest of the Americas. After all, we all fought for independence from a "foreign" power. Even English-speaking Canada, our long-lost cousins, whom, on the surface, we resemble in language and custom more than just about anyone else on the planet, seems different from us in its view toward Europe and our approach to "civilization."
Hold the pickles, hold the lettuce, special orders don't upset us: We have it our way. We're Americans. We're not exceptional, just different.
Maybe we're too rambunctious, too hard-headed, too conservative, too hot-blooded, too quick to react, too non-contemplative, too everything. I try to look at these as less "too muches" and more neutrals: It's who we are, for good, for ill, for better, for worse.
Nonetheless, I must admit that the "toos" still drive me crazy from time to time. Or even often.
* * *
Maybe we're more violent, too--I just don't know. I tend to think we're maybe less different than we might imagine ourselves to be. Europe and Canada have had mass shootings as well. It's just that we also have easier access to firearms and a cultural norm that says they're OK--corral or no corral--to use.
Having said all that--and, more or less, unapologetically so, or at least nonjudgmentally so--at times like these, when yet another shooting occurs in a public space, I have to agree that the Canadians and the Europeans are onto something: Limit access to guns, and you'll have fewer shootings and killings, in public or in private.
It seems incredibly simple, and yet it is an idea that stands no chance of gaining traction at this time. For when a mass shooting happens in Europe or Canada, there always seems to be an examining of the national conscience and an attempt to mend the social fabric. In the U.S., the opposite seems to happen now: The more shootings there are, the less contemplation occurs.
When a mass shooting happens in Europe or Canada, there seems to be a concerted effort to further limit access to firearms. In the U.S., again, we do the opposite: Another shooting just seems to prompt more calls for even fewer restrictions on access to firearms.
After Columbine and then eight years later, Virginia Tech, you'd think we would have gotten the message loud and clear and taken immediate action to curb access, limit gun ownership, or at least the types of guns people are allowed to own. But no. Instead our fearless leaders and class-action lawyers recommended we put in more metal detectors and pursued less restrictive gun laws. Funny, huh?
Even after Thursday's shooting here in Pittsburgh, all the focus seems to be on what the hospital and the university had done or not done to prevent this sort of episode from happening. The very afternoon of the shooting, I heard a colleague say, "See, if we had laws in place that would allow us to carry guns on campus, this problem would have been taken care of in a second." Given the general level of punch-drunkeness that occurred that afternoon, I don't know for sure whether he was joking or not.
Nevertheless, even our state's governor, Tom Corbett, weighed in on whether the institution had done enough to prevent this horrendous event from happening. "Obviously it's very disturbing, and I think we need to review exactly what happened and what happened to the lack of security at that facility," the governor was quoted as saying.
Coincidence that the university and the governor are locked in a heated battle over state funding of higher education with plans to cut several million dollars more of the state's appropriation? Cynical me thinks not so much.
So lots of treating symptoms, but not much dealing with the problem, which to me is essentially this: Why should your right to bear arms supersede my right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness? Why do I need to worry that I will be killed at work or at the gym or at the mall or sitting in my living room watching TV so that you can have unbridled access to all kinds of weaponry, the vast majority of of it out of proportion to your actual need?
You want to hunt? I don't really get it, but I know it's a cultural thing in Pennsylvania and other places. So fine, go hunt. A simple rifle should do the trick. Level the playing field a bit and keep it moderately powered and low-tech. Give the deer or the elk a chance to kick your ass if you can't shoot straight. Seems fair.
You feel you need protection at home? Hmmm, I'm not sure I get your reasoning, that having a loaded pistol will do the trick, especially when so much can go so wrong in such a scenario. As far as I can tell, nobody uses a pistol to hunt; they use it to threaten or kill. I don't understand why you would want to do this, and I certainly don't support it. Here's a case where some additional paraphernalia, like door and window locks, might just take care of your worries without the need to go all Dirty Harry on someone's personhood.
As you feel so strongly about this point, I can be a little flexible on this point--as long as you keep the firepower low and your actions are aimed at stunning and scaring off, rather than killing anything that moves. Oh, and limit one per customer. And consider yourself forewarned: If you mess this up, the privilege (not the right) goes away. Blam!
Everything else? No. Banned. Completely. No exceptions. You may hate it. (In fact, I'm sure you will.) You may fight it. (In fact, I know you will.) You may offer up your curious interpretations of what the "Founding Fathers" intended in the Second Amendment. And who really knows since none of us was around much in the 1780s, not even our most decrepit citizens--our senior members of Congress and the Supreme Court. My layperson's interpretation of the Second Amendment reads it as though we were simply being allowed to form state militias, National Guards, as needed. I see nothing in there about the right to bear arms in the form of AK-47s or armor-piercing bullets. If you're going to be a "strict constitutionalist," as you so enjoy repeating at loud volume, then you have to always be one, not just when it suits you. Them's the rules.
So bitch all you want, rant, wail, berate, and threaten. I will, nonetheless, prevail. It's over. No more. Stop the shooting and killing. Stop pretending it's about your freedom when it's really about your unchecked irresponsibility and about gunmaker profits. Stop it all now. NOW. I deserve to live in peace, and so do you. If you follow my lead on this, we'll get what I want but we'll also get what you and I both need.
Still not convinced? For added incentive, look at this way: Just think how much we'll piss off the Europeans and Canadians by tuning them out, taking action, getting this right, and then stating that this was our intention all along. We just had to do it in our own way, our time, when we were ready and thought it was the best for us, best for the world at large--but not because we were paying any attention to them.
American exceptionalism, American difference, America our way. Call it what you will. Let's stop shooting one another and get back to living well through our unique ability to annoy the world around us. Just imagine being able to shout, "We're number 1! we're number 1! USA! USA" due to a dramatic drop in gun-related violence and homicides.
It'll kill 'em!
I was never in any danger during this event. My office is at least three or four miles from the hospital, although it is a branch of my employer's operations, and, thus, when they went on lockdown in Oakland, so did we. I think everyone in my office felt a little nervous at first, dis-eased by the unknown, the drama, and the repeated and rapid-fire (if you'll pardon the expression) calls and texts received from our employer's post-Virginia Tech warning system. A few of us were inconvenienced because we had appointments at other offices near the hospital, but I think everyone was pretty clear on not needing to venture near the neighborhood after this incident.
So impact on us? Minimal. After a couple of hours of being stuck inside our offices, we relaxed and propped open the card swipe-protected door, so that we could go to the bathroom and the water fountain.
We even resorted to some black humor. One of my colleagues, upon hearing that a police officer had been grazed by a bullet in the shootout, joked, "I can hear it now, 'I shot the sheriff, but I did not kill no deputy.'"
Ha.
"Just make sure you're singing it like Bob Marley and not Eric Clapton," I quipped. "I can't stand the Clapton version of that song."
Double ha. We slay us, don't we?
Except that two people did get slayed, the shooter and a 25-year-old psychiatric nurse named Michael Schaab, who worked with geriatric patients and had just gotten engaged to his girlfriend in February. Apparently, too, this was the second (and last) child of Mr. Schaab's parents, Mary and Harry Schaab, to be murdered. Less than two years ago, their daughter Nancy, 26, was killed during a domestic dispute by her boyfriend.
If you were ever trying to find a pure example of the meaning of the word "tragedy," here's where you would start.
Of course, we didn't know any of this at the time. Nevertheless, that joke's not so funny anymore, is it? If it ever was.
Given the details that we now know, I do feel especially reprehensible for my part in trivializing the afternoon's events. No family should ever have to endure what the Schaabs are going through. My heart goes out to them. The whole city's, the entire nation's should as well.
I'm not some moral puritan who thinks you can't have a laugh, even a bitter pill of one, at someone or something else's expense. Gallows humor is a coping mechanism, pure and simple, something we do as a way to scare away the distress and alleviate the upset from horrific events. For good or for ill, I think we Americans have excelled at this over the last decade or more. Lordy, we've had to, given an up-and-down economy, lingering social ills, threats of domestic terrorism, and the bizarre, incendiary actions of some to impose their visions of law and order upon us. It's laugh or cry most days. The gods bless The Daily Show with Jon Stewart and the Colbert Report. Many of us would have caved ages ago without them.
Moreover, humor, black or otherwise, is just a part of our national character.
As I state to others elsewhere who decry some of the events that take place in our country, these now-almost common workplace shootings a case in point, we're Americans, not Europeans. We're not even Canadians. We made a conscious decision more than 200 years ago to separate ourselves from European rule and to embrace a New World culture.
While our cultural stock is made up of Europeans, it is only partly so. Besides, Europe's a big, diverse place. Our heritage hails from all parts of Europe, not just Britain or Northern or Western Europe. We are Southern European and Eastern European as well, as much Italian and Jewish as we are German, English, and Irish, I would argue. And we are also African, Latino, Asian, and indigenous as well. Heavily so and increasingly so and hooray for that.
I'd argue that we're actually spiritually more akin to Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, and the rest of the Americas. After all, we all fought for independence from a "foreign" power. Even English-speaking Canada, our long-lost cousins, whom, on the surface, we resemble in language and custom more than just about anyone else on the planet, seems different from us in its view toward Europe and our approach to "civilization."
Hold the pickles, hold the lettuce, special orders don't upset us: We have it our way. We're Americans. We're not exceptional, just different.
Maybe we're too rambunctious, too hard-headed, too conservative, too hot-blooded, too quick to react, too non-contemplative, too everything. I try to look at these as less "too muches" and more neutrals: It's who we are, for good, for ill, for better, for worse.
Nonetheless, I must admit that the "toos" still drive me crazy from time to time. Or even often.
* * *
Maybe we're more violent, too--I just don't know. I tend to think we're maybe less different than we might imagine ourselves to be. Europe and Canada have had mass shootings as well. It's just that we also have easier access to firearms and a cultural norm that says they're OK--corral or no corral--to use.
Having said all that--and, more or less, unapologetically so, or at least nonjudgmentally so--at times like these, when yet another shooting occurs in a public space, I have to agree that the Canadians and the Europeans are onto something: Limit access to guns, and you'll have fewer shootings and killings, in public or in private.
It seems incredibly simple, and yet it is an idea that stands no chance of gaining traction at this time. For when a mass shooting happens in Europe or Canada, there always seems to be an examining of the national conscience and an attempt to mend the social fabric. In the U.S., the opposite seems to happen now: The more shootings there are, the less contemplation occurs.
When a mass shooting happens in Europe or Canada, there seems to be a concerted effort to further limit access to firearms. In the U.S., again, we do the opposite: Another shooting just seems to prompt more calls for even fewer restrictions on access to firearms.
After Columbine and then eight years later, Virginia Tech, you'd think we would have gotten the message loud and clear and taken immediate action to curb access, limit gun ownership, or at least the types of guns people are allowed to own. But no. Instead our fearless leaders and class-action lawyers recommended we put in more metal detectors and pursued less restrictive gun laws. Funny, huh?
Even after Thursday's shooting here in Pittsburgh, all the focus seems to be on what the hospital and the university had done or not done to prevent this sort of episode from happening. The very afternoon of the shooting, I heard a colleague say, "See, if we had laws in place that would allow us to carry guns on campus, this problem would have been taken care of in a second." Given the general level of punch-drunkeness that occurred that afternoon, I don't know for sure whether he was joking or not.
Nevertheless, even our state's governor, Tom Corbett, weighed in on whether the institution had done enough to prevent this horrendous event from happening. "Obviously it's very disturbing, and I think we need to review exactly what happened and what happened to the lack of security at that facility," the governor was quoted as saying.
Coincidence that the university and the governor are locked in a heated battle over state funding of higher education with plans to cut several million dollars more of the state's appropriation? Cynical me thinks not so much.
So lots of treating symptoms, but not much dealing with the problem, which to me is essentially this: Why should your right to bear arms supersede my right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness? Why do I need to worry that I will be killed at work or at the gym or at the mall or sitting in my living room watching TV so that you can have unbridled access to all kinds of weaponry, the vast majority of of it out of proportion to your actual need?
You want to hunt? I don't really get it, but I know it's a cultural thing in Pennsylvania and other places. So fine, go hunt. A simple rifle should do the trick. Level the playing field a bit and keep it moderately powered and low-tech. Give the deer or the elk a chance to kick your ass if you can't shoot straight. Seems fair.
You feel you need protection at home? Hmmm, I'm not sure I get your reasoning, that having a loaded pistol will do the trick, especially when so much can go so wrong in such a scenario. As far as I can tell, nobody uses a pistol to hunt; they use it to threaten or kill. I don't understand why you would want to do this, and I certainly don't support it. Here's a case where some additional paraphernalia, like door and window locks, might just take care of your worries without the need to go all Dirty Harry on someone's personhood.
As you feel so strongly about this point, I can be a little flexible on this point--as long as you keep the firepower low and your actions are aimed at stunning and scaring off, rather than killing anything that moves. Oh, and limit one per customer. And consider yourself forewarned: If you mess this up, the privilege (not the right) goes away. Blam!
Everything else? No. Banned. Completely. No exceptions. You may hate it. (In fact, I'm sure you will.) You may fight it. (In fact, I know you will.) You may offer up your curious interpretations of what the "Founding Fathers" intended in the Second Amendment. And who really knows since none of us was around much in the 1780s, not even our most decrepit citizens--our senior members of Congress and the Supreme Court. My layperson's interpretation of the Second Amendment reads it as though we were simply being allowed to form state militias, National Guards, as needed. I see nothing in there about the right to bear arms in the form of AK-47s or armor-piercing bullets. If you're going to be a "strict constitutionalist," as you so enjoy repeating at loud volume, then you have to always be one, not just when it suits you. Them's the rules.
So bitch all you want, rant, wail, berate, and threaten. I will, nonetheless, prevail. It's over. No more. Stop the shooting and killing. Stop pretending it's about your freedom when it's really about your unchecked irresponsibility and about gunmaker profits. Stop it all now. NOW. I deserve to live in peace, and so do you. If you follow my lead on this, we'll get what I want but we'll also get what you and I both need.
Still not convinced? For added incentive, look at this way: Just think how much we'll piss off the Europeans and Canadians by tuning them out, taking action, getting this right, and then stating that this was our intention all along. We just had to do it in our own way, our time, when we were ready and thought it was the best for us, best for the world at large--but not because we were paying any attention to them.
American exceptionalism, American difference, America our way. Call it what you will. Let's stop shooting one another and get back to living well through our unique ability to annoy the world around us. Just imagine being able to shout, "We're number 1! we're number 1! USA! USA" due to a dramatic drop in gun-related violence and homicides.
It'll kill 'em!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






